Who cares how old it is, Chrono Trigger is older then Starcraft is. Plus Starcraft has Kerrigan, that alone puts it in my top five games of all time. In fact this is a picture thread so how about pictures of all five of my favorite games form 5th to 1st.
Karen S'jet representing Homeworld:
+THE Perfect voice.
-You'll never EVER see her though.

Kid representing Chrono Cross:
+Entertaining and spunky, more then willing to get down and dirty.
-She has a habit of...wait where the hell is my wallet?

Sarah Kerrigan representing Starcraft:
+Who doesn't find a successful and independent woman attractive.
-Kinda picky, in taste and physically

Fall-From-Grace representing Planescape:Torment
+She's an agnostic celibate succubus cleric
-She's an agnostic celibate succubus cleric

SHODAN representing System Shock 2
+She was made to be the Matriarch
-Dissociative personality disorder
