Hey guys, I'm locking this thread for a day because it looks like a cooldown period might be worthwhile. I've only briefly glanced over the last few pages and won't weigh in until I get a better look. In the meantime, if a sounding board would be of help to anyone, please feel free to reach out to me over PM.
--
Okay, thread unlocked.
After reading through the last few pages here, and the fallout of this discussion elsewhere, I'd like to raise an issue that I hope everyone will consider going forward. This goes to the core of what it means to be a community.
I think it's important to recognize a difference between "comfort" and "safety."
Comfort is, like, what happens when everyone's politically correct on every issue, and we mind our Ps and Qs to an insane level for fear that we're going to offend each other. We sit on heavenly clouds and play harps and generally agree how cool Magus is. It may not be particularly conducive to discussion that's intellectually fulfilling. Comfort, then, is kind of expected to go out the window once some debate starts up on an Internet forum.
Safety is freedom from being harassed, both in the sense of repetitive pot-shots and in the sense of being repeatedly confronted with something you've indicated is deeply disturbing. I think of safety kind of like, there's this big green button you can push to make a painful situation stop. Or maybe the big green button buys you the breathing room you need. There's the "logoff" button, true, but if that's all we're relying on, I don't think we're a community in any meaningful sense. Safety is every community member's right, and something we all need to respect.
I know I haven't gone into the depth this facet of online community life deserves, so I hope we can develop it further, and clarify it. In a well functioning community, safety is something we should be able to maintain spontaneously by just backing off once the line's been crossed. Sometimes it's hard to see in the heat of the moment, and sometimes we stumble across that line completely by accident. It happens. But once it's pretty clear that it's happened, the person who stepped over that line needs to put the breaks on and give the other community member some room. Even if this idea makes some members uncomfortable, I think them's just got to be the rules.