Chrono Compendium

Zenan Plains - Site Discussion => General Discussion => Topic started by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2005, 12:35:31 pm

Title: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2005, 12:35:31 pm
Today is September 11th, 2005. It has been 4 years since the tragic events that happened in New York. My question is to you,

Where were you when you heard the news, and how did it affect your day?

I had gotten up that morning and went down to the living room. My dad a few minutes later turned on the TV to find the channel he had left it on the night before, stating

Quote from: TV Channel
Were are sorry for the inconvinonce but we will not airing our regular shows this morning due to the tragic events in New York.


My dad was like "What?" and he turned the channel to a local station and we watched in horror as the first tower fell on live television. Then the second fell. I was wrecked the whole day. I just wanted to wake up from this horrible nightmare, but wasn't a nightmare, it was real.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Kazuki on September 11, 2005, 01:46:18 pm
I was nearly 11 years old in 5th grade at the time...I learned about it in school, when all the teachers were whispering around to each other like it was a complete conspiracy until our 5th grade teacher, a great woman, told us about what had happened. I was a bit concerned for my Dad, who at the time worked in New York at Pfizer (Only a block away from the UN building), but then I got a call down to the office with a message that he was fine. It really didn't affect my young life too much, as I'd lost nobody.

However, in retrospect, I wish I had been a bit more respectful and involved in the relief efforts, but I was young(er) and foolish then.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Legend of the Past on September 11, 2005, 01:58:47 pm
I was 11, in sixth grade. My friend told me over the phone, and I coulden't believe it and thought he was kidding me. Then, later in the evening, I heard it was true. It wasn't really something that bothered me, just like everything else about the US, but hey, terrorism stinks worldwide, so meh.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2005, 02:27:54 pm
Quote from: Legend of the Past
I was 11, in sixth grade. My friend told me over the phone, and I coulden't believe it and thought he was kidding me. Then, later in the evening, I heard it was true. It wasn't really something that bothered me, just like everything else about the US, but hey, terrorism stinks worldwide, so meh.


At least we all have the same views.

Terrorists are teh SUCK!
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Daniel Krispin on September 11, 2005, 02:32:08 pm
That was, I think, the third day of first year university for me. It scarcely affected me, save for a matter of interest. I thought 'wow, this is really happening; this will be something to remember', but I still went to school, and life went on as normal. My statics prof told us a few days later the mechanics of why the buildings fell: not the crash, not the explosion, but the fires due to the jet-fuel that weakened the support columns. That day felt like it was historical. But beyond that, I actually don't see that event as all that big of a deal, and I'm not sure why its still being given that much press.

More people die from civils wars, from disasters, and all such things all the time around the world, yet none hear of them. It is the shock of it, that the US was actually struck by foreign terrorism, that accounts for its remembrance, not the loss of human life - quite simply, the US has a strong hand but a weak heart, and is easily frightened by a strike on its home soil. If this had happened in Britain, I think after two years it would have been mostly forgotten - Britain is very resiliant, as shown during the air raids duruing WWII, which were far more devestating than September 11 was. The World Trade Centre thing was more flashy, more noticeable because of the long spell of peace that had descended on the US, but none the more terrible than a hundred other things both now around the world, and in the past hundred years. I do not think that we will be remembring hurricane Katrina in quite the same way in four years. Or many of the earthquakes and the like that killed many more people. Or even the civil wars and oppressive regimes about the world that are causing just as much - and more - death and distress. I look at these things with the long view of history, and beside such calamities of the past hundred years as the Somme, the Holocaust, the fire-bombing of Dresden by the British, Stalin's exterminations (that is probably the worst of the last century), this seems rather minor. It only touched very near to Americans, which is probably why it doesn't affect me much - I'm not American.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2005, 02:35:40 pm
Hey, it doesn't matter, but shock that people can go off and murder thousands of people just for their religious cause is sickening.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Daniel Krispin on September 11, 2005, 02:50:23 pm
Quote from: nightmare975
Hey, it doesn't matter, but shock that people can go off and murder thousands of people just for their religious cause is sickening.


True. Interestingly, though religion is used as a driving force, the basis of it is still territorial. Why don't they attack the Hindus? Why only the West, which is mostly Christian? Not because they are Christian, but because they are (or rather we are) the wealthy and oppressive west to their eyes. I think that lies at the heart of it, otherwise China and the east would have been struck, too, and they haven't. Of the east, who's been struck by terrorism? Russia. Why? Because they attacked Afghanistan. These things, as much as the bombers and the like might think it to be religious, is primarially in origin territorial.

Though, in some ways, the attack upon the world trade centre was not as much a terrorist act as some others (ie. the incessent suicide bombings in Israel and the like), and was rather an act of careful war. Think about it this way. What were the targets? The World Trade Centre, the Pentagon, and maybe the President. That is the Economy, the Military, and the Political centres of the United States. If their sole objective had been to cause terror, they would have struck in the middle of the day, when many more were in the buildings. But they struck in the morning, when they were few. Actually, I think that those events are nearer to a surgical military strike with civilian casualties alongside, rather than true terrorism. Actually, the atomic bombs can be considered much more an act of terrorism - it was meant to frighten the Japanese into surrender - come to think of it. As can the fire-bombing of Dresden. The US also practices what is called Terror-Bombing - they call it 'Shock and Awe' now, a euphamism so that avoid using the term 'terror', but it serves the same end. I'm not saying that such actions are good or right - only that everyone, to some measure, does them.

But, you know, we really shouldn't be shocked by any of this. It's human nature, it's the way of the world, and all of that, and is really to be expected. 2700 years ago it was seen as the kingly responsability of the kings of Assyria to go upon a yearly conquest in the name of their god Ashur - they killed and dispossessed many hundreds of thousands. Legend will likely remember those stories all too well, as the Israelites were amongst those dispossessed by the Assyrian kings. And the Assyrians did not simply kill and conquer - they were a nation of terrorists or, rather, subjegated the people through acts of terror: flayings, beheadings, and all such things, if the people did not submit. These were the boasts of their kings. The Aztecs of some 500 years ago slaughtered hundreds of thousands in the century before Cortez arrived - these being mostly from their neighbours - in the name of their sun-god. And even those that did not fight in the name of their religion have commited acts of violence in their conquests and wars. Three names, those of Stalin, Mussolini, and Hitler, are best remembered, but even in this century there are many more. In light of all of that, and considering that history repeats itself, it's only a matter of time.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 11, 2005, 02:51:06 pm
This was significant.  America felt secure in it's strength, it felt like terrorism, wars, and things of that nature are only things that happen over there, not here.  We are safe in America!

9/11 changed that.  It was the worst single attack on the US ever.  Worse than Peral Harbor, which brought us into WW2.  It is significant because it was an eye-opener.  It showed that the US is no invulnerable.  It showed that America must fight in order to protect itself, rather than protect itself by simply being great.  It bloodied our nose, and showed that we must protect ourselves, or be lost.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 11, 2005, 02:54:34 pm
Quote
Interestingly, though religion is used as a driving force, the basis of it is still territorial. Why don't they attack the Hindus?


They do...  Pakistan and India are very hostile to each other.  But I don't think its so much territorial, as religious.  Right now, Christianity and Islam are the two largest religions, and so the radical Islamics aim to take down their biggest rival.  Terrorist are very much on a religious war agianst the US.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Daniel Krispin on September 11, 2005, 02:58:22 pm
Quote from: Sentenal
This was significant.  America felt secure in it's strength, it felt like terrorism, wars, and things of that nature are only things that happen over there, not here.  We are safe in America!

9/11 changed that.  It was the worst single attack on the US ever.  Worse than Peral Harbor, which brought us into WW2.  It is significant because it was an eye-opener.  It showed that the US is no invulnerable.  It showed that America must fight in order to protect itself, rather than protect itself by simply being great.  It bloodied our nose, and showed that we must protect ourselves, or be lost.


Yes, exactly. Hopefully, they did learn, and if such a thing were ever to happen again, they could stand like the British did to the London Blitz: firm and without claim of surrender. The US has incredible military might, but lacks psychological strength to fight a war if it strikes her bounderies; if she is to fight terrorism, the people must steel themselves up and put on a firm 'never-surrender, come what may' attitude, and basically say 'do your worst'. It may sound too emotionless, but is the neccessary, probably the only way, to fight terrorism - don't let it cause terror, and it has lost its sting.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 11, 2005, 03:02:11 pm
Unfortunatly, the will you speak of is lost on a certain part of the nation, who seek to rather make amends than to fight.  I won't go any further, for risk of a political debate.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2005, 03:14:06 pm
Quote from: Sentenal
Unfortunatly, the will you speak of is lost on a certain part of the nation, who seek to rather make amends than to fight.  I won't go any further, for risk of a political debate.

I think you and I agree more strongly and on more issues than you would be comfortable to admit. The left in America is not what Rush Limbaugh makes it out to be. =P

More on the main topic of this thread after lunch!
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2005, 04:49:20 pm
I was just going to sleep as the towers were struck. Three hours later it my dad called me. He was in tears and told me to turn on the news, then went on about how the Pentagon was gone, and the Twin Towers were gone. He was shocked. So I was shocked too, because I’d gotten only three hours of sleep and because my dad doesn’t cry.

That summer I had a roommate who was brand new to the University and had just come from Hong Kong. My talking woke him up, and by the time I had hung up and was going to look at my computer to see the news, he asked what was going on. I don’t remember what I said.

What I do remember, however, is my very first coherent response. I specifically had the image of United States aircraft carrier in my mind, and I told my roommate that we—the U.S.—would never stand for this. Unfortunately, my half-asleep shocked response was to be the very mirror of official U.S. foreign policy for years to come. But I wasn’t thinking about that.

I got dressed and went to watch television in the lounge, where a bunch of people from my floor had gathered to watch CNN. By then both towers had collapsed, the Pentagon was in flames, the fourth airliner had long since crashed, and the media had cancelled all commercials and were pooling their resources. I got to watch (and rewatch) images of the towers collapsing many times, and goodness gracious, but I cannot remember a word of the commentary. That was when the cable news networks began doing their tickers at the bottom of the screen—something that has continued ever since—and I remember reading that they had evacuated the Space Needle and Columbia Tower in Seattle, as well as other high-profile facilities in the area. (Years later, it came out that the Columbia Tower had been one of al Qaeda’s intended targets in a larger attack plan, which was scrapped due to infeasibility.)

I think the lack of sleep is really what makes that day stand out in my mind. It is much harder to deal with anything when you’re tired, so my emotions were running high all day. I went down to the exercise room on the recreation level to vent some frustration on an exercise bike. I watched the television there, too. They were already suspecting that it was Osama bin Laden, but they didn’t know yet. President Bush, like the coward that he is, was in flight with full military escort for most of the day. Presumably this was because the government didn’t know if further attacks would be forthcoming, and in that kind of situation, being in the air surrounded by fighter jets is probably the safest place. Cheney was in his famously “undisclosed location.”

I am one of life’s least emotional human beings. By midafternoon I had mostly gotten over it. But the zeitgeist had utterly consumed me. The president spoke live on the air that evening, and the Congress sang on the steps of the Capitol, and vowed to hold session tomorrow. Late that evening I went to a hastily arranged group counseling session that night, as did most of the people on my floor, and listened to people prattle on about whatever it is they were prattling on about. I didn’t really care.

I went to bed very tired. I had lost no one, lost nothing. Seattle was far away from the action.

The thing that really stood out to me in the aftermath of September 11, and something which I may never see again in my lifetime, was the utterly quiet airspace. I live in Seattle, underneath a commercial air traffic corridor. Seattle’s airspace has large jetliners, private jets and propeller aircraft, medical helicopters, news helicopters, floating tour planes, private small aircraft…and for three days, all of that was gone. The sky was utterly silent. It was the silence that stood out the most. I knew that somewhere, up there, U.S. fighter jets were patrolling every American city, but I never heard one, never saw one.

The aftermath had some other curious incidents, too. We found out over the next few days that all the military bases were on high alert, with orders to shoot trespassers. I also remember everyone tripping over themselves to give blood. It stunned me, even then, just how silly this was. That’s way too much blood; I’ll bet a lot of it went to waste. And it struck me even more that Americans were eager to “do their part” to lend a hand in this disaster, but that donating blood is what they came up with. What a stupid, selfish reaction. It isn’t practical, it involves no sacrifice whatsoever, and it gives a false sense of accomplishment. I suppose, for some people, it was their way of trying to console themselves. For others, it was herd thinking. Other people were giving blood, so so would they. I don’t think most Americans understand what sacrifice really is.

I remember a political cartoon soon thereafter, by some conservative bloke I didn’t like. It was an elephant and a donkey, arm-in-arm, and they were saying something like “To arms, old chum?” “To arms, good friend.” Yeah…for a few weeks, there was no political bickering in this country. I will never forget it. Unfortunately, this unprecedented cooperation allowed for the passage of incredibly bad legislation, such as the PATRIOT Act and all manner of other terrible thing. Perhaps you saw the news on Friday, when the U.S. 4th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that, pursuant to legislation passed by Congress in the aftermath of September 11, the President of the United States has the authority to detain U.S. citizens indefinitely, without criminal charges. Outrageous.

Briefly, the entire world stood with us—a universal goodwill that has since vanished like a mirage. (Perhaps hardcore conservatives would say that a mirage is all it really was, but I disagree. I think we wasted something wonderful.) President Bush soon started wearing that little Stars and Stripes broach on his left lapel, and most other national leaders and top-ranking businesspeople eventually followed. Across the nation, American flags sprung up on every street corner and in every living room window. It was like something out of Nazi Germany, except the U.S. wasn’t evil yet. Today, if anything, there are even more flags on display than there were four years ago.

A military response was inevitable. The blame got pinned on Afghanistan pretty fast. I remember the Taliban issuing a statement calling on the U.S. not to attack their country. Tough shit for them; we launched an invasion pretty fast. However, we did hold off just long enough to make it look as though it were not a knee-jerk reaction. At the time I thought it was a symbol of our government’s prudent military wisdom. However, knowing the Bush administration as I know do, it seems more likely that Dubya had spent that time trying to see if there was a way he could pin the blame on Iraq instead of a nobody country like Afghanistan.

Pakistan’s leader, Pervez Musharraf, was very quick to declare “allegiance” to the United States. I believe he (correctly) perceived that, had he not done so, we would have invaded his country too. I have admired his leadership ever since; he’s a good guy, in charge of a country whose rank-and-file people are very much opposed to the West.

A couple of weeks after September 11, the school year began, and I used my position as a columnist at the newspaper to write editorials on the subject. I think I still have them.

So those were my September 11 experiences. But there is one last thing I want to mention. In that first week, even in that first day, I remember thinking that the nation’s response was as extreme as it could possibly have been. Insofar as are concerned the reactions of ordinary, everyday U.S. citizens, we could have been nuked in twenty American cities, and our response could not have been much more profound than it was. In other words…we overreacted. And here we are, four years later…still overreacting. “These colors don’t run.”

Regrettably, I have to agree with Daniel Krispin that, in absolute terms, the September 11 attacks were nothing as important as we made them out to be. More people die from no health care and extreme poverty, and yet we care little to stop these things. And, so, that we are still making so much ado about Semptember 11 today is frankly embarrassing.

However, inasmuch as the September 11 attacks shaped American culture and American policymaking, they are a crucial turning point in world history. The American culture shifted to the conservative right with the force of an earthquake. Our foreign policy immediately became militaristic and preemptory. American citizens became xenophobic and racist, and responded to the perceived Islamic threat by strengthening their Christian evangelism. My dad said, once upon a time, that the September 11 attacks were the Pearl Harbor of our generation. That’s true, I think. But the difference is that we have sense entered a kind of war that may be unwinnable. We are fighting against “terror.” We have reified the enemy. You can’t do that. You can’t beat an idea with guns and missiles.

President Bush says we have an enemy, and its name is Terror. But not only am I not sure that Terror is our true enemy; I am not even sure we have an enemy at all. And if we do, I don’t think Terror is its name. I think the real threat to America is that we’ve got religious fanatics reading from their Koran on one continent and religious fanatics reading from their Bible on another. These two powers want to clash, and, by God, they will…so long as they remain in control of their respective societies.

I realize now, four years after the attacks, that our response to September 11 was childish, and ill-advised. The initial Afghanistan invasion was a good move. Everything that came after it was wrong. We failed to actually secure that country and build peace there. The government doesn’t control the country, we still have thousands of American troops committed there, and Osama bin Laden, Mullah Omar, and other unsavory characters still run free. Al Qaeda itself has evolved from a tangible terrorist organization into a symbol of Islamic fanaticism; it can never be defeated now, in terms of a direct confrontation. America may or may not be more “safe” in physical terms than it was four years ago—John Kerry was absolutely correct about the abject vulnerability of our ports of entry, transportation infrastructure, and energy installations, and Bush has never acted to shore these up—but whether or not our city walls are stronger and thicker, goodness knows we have more enemies at the gates now than we did four years ago. That right there is the essential error in President Bush’s foreign policy. He treats the whole world as being “with us, or against us”—even our allies. As a result, America is now one of the most despised nations on Earth.

I was surprised when so many countries offered relief to us, following Hurricane Katrina. But once I thought about it, I bet many of them got a secret pleasure out of simultaneously offering help to the needy and humility to the mighty. I can’t blame them. They’re in their rights.

The terrorists, whomever they are and wherever they live, realize that no single bomb or attack could ever destroy the United States. Only terror itself can do that. We could have defeated the terrorists…by not being terrorized. But instead we declared a War on Terror, with a capital “T,” and from that day on, the United States has been in greater and greater peril—not the peril of destruction, but the peril of obscurity. We are fast falling from the world stage as a major power…and history may well show that September 11, 2001, was the catalyst for all of that. Look how we responded the attacks of that day. We were terrorized. Instead of denying the terrorists their prize, we put them front-and-center in American life. The course of our nation was permanently changed. We have alienated ourselves from most of the planet. We have wasted our goodwill abroad. We have wasted the economy. We have wasted the military. We have wasted everything we have to waste, and momentum we have lost will take its toll.

My incoherent response on that morning, thinking of the United States aircraft carrier and the wrath of God reprisal that we would surely deliver to those barbarians who had struck at us…that was the same thing the Bush administration thought, and has lived out ever since. He and his base of supporters known as the radical religious right have succeeded in taking over one of America’s great political parties—the country itself is not yet a theocracy, but the Republican Party is—and these evangelicals are driving American politics, using God as a battering ram on almost every issue: crime and punishment, human rights, health care, taxation, energy, regulation, social services…and foreign policy.

And I think to myself—with chagrin and dismay and even a little honest to goodness fear—what a stunning failure. What a colossal blunder. Will the United States ever recover from this? We succeeded in allowing the fear of terrorism to embolden the worst president this country has ever had. Christian extremists roam the borders with guns, bomb abortion clinics, assault black people and Muslims…and what they do inside the law would fill an ocean. When President Bush declared the “War on Terror,” I think that was the day the terrorists “already won.”

The future is uncertain. So long as we memorialize September 11 as a justification to assail the world with our “armies of democracy,” we are doomed. So long as ordinary Americans submit to the terrorism they claim to hate, and look upon the rest of the world with suspicion and anger, we are doomed. So long as we continue supporting the political party that gratifies our childish lust for the utter destruction of some tangible enemy, we are doomed. There may simply come a point of no return. Maybe we are not there yet; maybe we already passed it. Hari Seldon pointed out that once you can see a cultural shift occurring, it is too late to stop it. That is the basic limitation that defines the science of psychohistory. And although the man is fictional and the science isn’t real, the premise is sound. People like Bill O’Reilly, James Dobson, Rush Limbaugh, Pat Robertson, and Jerry Falwell command assaults on intellectualism and progressivism, forcing America’s ambitions into the strange, contorted shape of a juggernaut under incredible pressure both from within and without. We are an angry, proud, stupid people with incredible economic power and vast waistlines, who waste resources like confetti, who denigrate those who could be our greatest friends, who like our leaders to speak in terms we understand, and who blame the liberal American values that made this country great for all of our ills. America is in an irrational, homicidal state of mind. We’re furious, and we have really big guns. It’s just not a good place for this country to be.

In this uncertain future is the possibility of the total destruction we fear, so unlikely and yet, because of our own overreaction, also a uniquely real possibility unlike ever before. Christian neoconservatives are leading assaults on most of the world, and even on American society itself. Like the Emperor and his death star, they are squeezing too tight, and in the end they will lose their grip. If that comes to pass in a way that rains destruction upon us, we will damn them too late, for we will be damned right along with them.

In this uncertain future is the possibility of complete obscurity, as we squander our superpower over the world and sit idly by while countries like China and the new, budding European Union pass us by in ambition and prudence. I always hesitate in drawing comparisons between Imperial Rome and the United States, but one comparison that I have long held to be completely accurate is that Rome began its decline long before it began losing its military supremacy. There was an entire century before the decay of the culture caused the military to rot as well. Is our culture rotting, now? There are many potential national diseases to which a country could succumb, from every political spectrum and social quarter, but the one that threatens America today is called the “radical right,” and it encompasses both fanatic neoconservative culture that opposes the process of globalization and progressivism, and the evangelical Christian resurgence that now controls much of the country and represses liberty. The health of the radical right is inversely proportional to the health of the United States, and if, against the odds, the radical right changes the course of this country away from greatness and toward the dark ages, then obscurity will be our gift to our children in the generations to come. Of course, it won’t be the same sort of obscurity enjoyed by, say, Belgium. No, we’ll still have those aircraft carriers, those nuclear warheads…it’d be a very dangerous obscurity, perhaps in the vein of post-Soviet Russia, except led by xenophobic religious extremists.

And in this uncertain future is a redemption of the United States of America as a worthy director on the world stage of human evolution. I want to think this is still the most likely of all the possibilities, but I just don’t know. Americans had the chance to denounce the Bush administration as a drunken aberration, by voting for John Kerry in the 2004 election. But that didn’t happen. Bush won a small but decisive majority, and Republicans made deeper gains in the Congress. That sent a message to the world that in the past ten years, the United States has gone in a very different direction. Nevertheless, so much of this can change if the pied pipers and puppetmasters of the radical right lose their grip on that great sea of fickle, stupid, ordinary Americans. If the people start voting against the Republican vision, much of these superficial despotic policies can be overturned relatively quickly. And, to the extent they are superficial, there may be but little damage done. It remains to be seen. However, the longer Republicans maintain absolute power over the White House, the Congress, the Judiciary, the states, the media, and the religious establishment, the deeper their damage will become, and the harder it will be to unmake.

An uncertain future, definitely. That is the legacy of September 11. I lost no family, no friends, but perhaps I lost my country.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 11, 2005, 05:38:20 pm
I don't want to argue here.  I really don't.  I had to force myself to stop reading half-way through.  I'll only say that by not attacking these people who come agianst us is wrong.  It shows weakness.  It shows that you can do whatever you want to us, we will ignore you.  These terrorist arn't out for attension.  Us ignoring them will not stop them from attacking us.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2005, 05:42:05 pm
Quote from: Sentenal
Us ignoring them will not stop them from attacking us.


Did we ignore them? I don't think so! We bombed Afganistan to bloody pulp! We took down Saddam Hussein! One of the biggest dictators out in this day and age! We took him down! Where the fuck were you the past 4 years?
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2005, 05:42:25 pm
Quote from: Sentenal
I don't want to argue here.  I really don't.  I had to force myself to stop reading half-way through.  I'll only say that by not attacking these people who come agianst us is wrong.  It shows weakness.  It shows that you can do whatever you want to us, we will ignore you.  These terrorist arn't out for attension.  Us ignoring them will not stop them from attacking us.

Good thing you stopped halfway through. The first half is simply my recollections of September 11 and the immediate aftermath. The second half is...accusatory. =P

Striking at an enemy is fine. But real life is not as simple as we would have it be given our current foreign policies. Ask yourself, who our enemy really is. Today's easy answers are tomorrow's colossal woes. A good foreign policy understands the times, the customs, and the intentions of people everywhere.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 11, 2005, 05:50:46 pm
Our enemy right now are the radical Islamics who want to destroy us.  And we have taken the fight to them.  And I think we have been successful in many respects, though not all.  If a country harbors one of these radicals, and will not turn them over, we will forcefully do it.  Otherwise, they will conspire to attack us.  Our leadership has an obligation to do whatever they feel nessisary in order to protect this country.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2005, 06:02:09 pm
Quote from: Sentenal
Our enemy right now are the radical Islamics who want to destroy us.

I agree that Islam is one of our most prominent enemies. We have no argument here.

Quote from: Sentenal
And we have taken the fight to them.

This is not so. Just or unjust, our war against Iraq has inspired thousands of people who were not terrorists before, both inside Iraq and outside. They have rejected our war and have taken up terrorism to propel the insurgency against us. Now our only choice is to defeat them by force or guile, or to submit to them and withdraw from the country. Neither is a very good choice because of the costs involved; the correct strategy would have been to never make terrorists of them in the first place.

Quote from: Sentenal
And I think we have been successful in many respects, though not all.

When I look at Iraq, my heart sinks. My stomach fills with a cold dread. Why is this? Because we brought democracy to Iraq, and look what they're doing with it: They are creating an Islamic republic. And the reason this angers and dejects me so, is because of what this entails for Iraq's women. We have brought untold misery to that country, much of which is yet to come.

Success? We attacked a country to stop it from using weaopns of mass destruction against us...Those weapons never existed. We attacked to bring freedom to the Iraqi people...They are now embracing Islamic rule of the state. We attacked to depose a dictator and bring peace to the Iraqi people...The insurgency is killing more Iraqis than Saddam ever did. We attacked to fight the terrorists abroad so we wouldn't have to fight them at home...The occupation has created tens of thousands of terrorists. And let's not forget the American casualties, the enormous drain on our economy, the deficit spending, and the terrorist bombings in London, which debunks the premise that we have erected a containment shield around the Middle East. Iraq was a failure. You are right that the underlying goal of making Iraq a closer U.S. ally than it was under Saddam Hussein was certainly a good idea. But the way we went about doing it...was utterly, miserably wrong.

Quote from: Sentenal
If a country harbors one of these radicals, and will not turn them over, we will forcefully do it.

If nothing else, Sentenal, we can learn from our mistakes so as not to repeat them. Iraq was a failed war. Why on Earth should we launch further wars under the same policy? Why not change the policy first...and then we'll talk about war.

Quote from: Sentenal
Our leadership has an obligation to do whatever they feel nessisary in order to protect this country.

Our leadership has an obligation to uphold the prosperity of this country and the wellbeing of its citizens. It has succeeded in neither.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: BlueThunder on September 11, 2005, 06:14:28 pm
Today is a sad day for people who lost family and friends in 9/11.We should all wish the best for the familys who lost loved ones on this sad day.  :(
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2005, 06:19:31 pm
Quote from: BlueThunder
Today is a sad day for people who lost family and friends in 9/11.We should all wish the best for the familys who lost loved ones on this sad day.  :(

Aye, it is a sad anniversary. There is no doubt of that. But wishes are for the powerless and hope is for the weak. If your ambition is to never let such a disaster happen again, then you must seize the power to do more than simply wish and hope for it. The victims of September 11 are dead and gone forever. The best way to honor their memory is to aspire for a better country, and make it so.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: BlueThunder on September 11, 2005, 06:25:55 pm
I agree with you. We can't wish them back.I personaly didn't lose anyone.If you did that would make you more correct.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 11, 2005, 06:26:29 pm
Like I said, I really don't want to argue here, so I'll just respectfully disagree.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Daniel Krispin on September 11, 2005, 06:27:14 pm
Quote from: Lord J esq
I was just going to sleep... I lost no family, no friends, but perhaps I lost my country.


That was well written. Admittedly, I only skimmed through it, but you do make some interesting observations of a transition in American culture. I may not agree with you in absolutely everything you said, but you did indeed bring up some valid points - obviously I belong to the religious right, and I know that you stand on the liberal left and thus I am by my ideology mostly opposed to you, but I cannot deny that when one brings religion into politics and foreign policy it is dangerous ground. It used to be, two thousand years ago, that Christians abstained from even joining the armies of Rome - I wonder when that changed... with Constantine, I suppose. But anyway, as a Canadian, I've never been quite sure if I'm for or against Bush; certainly, I was wary of his invasion of Iraq, and absolutely against it when the UN disallowed it. I'm glad that, in the face of the rule of Canadian people, that our Prime Minister kept us from it. Follow the UN I say - it is there for a reason.

Anyway, I found several of your points rather insightful, especially that which regarded it leading to the obscurity of America on the world stage is rather interesting, a fear that only time will prove to be right or wrong. Maybe its my position as a foreigner (ie. Canadian), but I cannot fully disagree with you as Sentenal did. I stand more in the middle, a little unsure, I think. And if nothing else, you DID write it well.

One more thing regarding what you said.
Quote from: Lord J Esq
It was like something out of Nazi Germany, except the U.S. wasn’t evil yet.


An interesting point, here. My grandfather fought in the very last days of WWII on the Eastern front for Germany (in the last ditch efforts of the Germans, and as they broke and fled west again - he was injured and evacuated in the wake of the Russian advance). But what he has told me, that the politics after September 11 struck him as in some measure similar to that in 1939 Germany. I doubt history will directly repeat itself - and certainly they have yet to - but nonetheless, there is an interestingly slight parallell there, I think.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: BlueThunder on September 11, 2005, 06:34:45 pm
I know you didn't say anything bad about Bush but he's delt with alot of tradgities.First 9/11 now Hurricane Katrinia,for all of that it makes him a good president.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Silvercry on September 11, 2005, 07:27:54 pm
I was 22.  

I remember it quite well.  I was brushing my teeth, having just showered after coing home from PT.  I was wearing my BDU pants and brown undershirt, fuming silently about another crappy day as a soldier in the US Army.  My wife called out to me form the kitchen where she had just turned on the news while making me breakfast: A plane had hit the World Trade Center.

Being a career aviation man, the thought that someone would crash a plane into a building intentionally never occurred to me.  Instead, I was marveling at the level of stupidity required and all the things that would have to fail and go wrong before a plane would even came close to clipping the antenna at the top of the WTC  (I must have left my Occam's Razor in the bathroom).  It wasn’t until I saw the second plane hit that the reality of the situation began to dawn on me.

Needless to say, the trip to the base where I worked was surreal.  The threat-con has skyrocketed in response to the attack.  And once I was there, the day became a blur.  Airfield security became iron clad, in a move that was as frantic as it was methodical.  Looking back, I wonder how much of all the running around we did was to ensure the post was secure, and how much of it was top keep the rank-and-file soldiers from thinking to hard about what it all meant.  Because we all new what it meant, even if were to busy to converse about it.

It meant: Pack your sh*t.  We’re going somewhere real soon.  And someone will pay.[/b]  Suddenly, being a soldier had gone from crappy to vital.

My perspective changed that day.  This new perspective remains to this day.

I don’t have a point.  I’m only sharing my story.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2005, 07:32:03 pm
Wow, so did you fight in the Middle East?
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Silvercry on September 11, 2005, 07:54:01 pm
No, I did not.  By the time my unit was actually mobilized, my active duty commitment was over.  I had never intended to re-enlist, in fact I had planed my entire initial enlistment so that come the day it was over I could walk into a civilian job doing the exact same this I did in the Army, only with more pay, fewer hours, nicer clothes, and 24/7air conditioning.  

Many of the people I served with did go to Iraq, however.  Not all of them came back in once peace  -- or at all.

I am in the Reserves now, and subject to being called up at any time.  And should the call come – well, my BDU’s still fit, I can still shoot expert with my rifle, and run a 6 minute mile.

To quote one Janus Zeal:

“If the world is to be destroyed, so be it. If it is my fate to die, I must simply laugh.”
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sir Frog on September 11, 2005, 08:11:52 pm
Does anyone remember what happened to Bill Maher?
Who here thinks the American public overreacted to his comments?
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: BlueThunder on September 11, 2005, 08:15:43 pm
No I don't and I'm glad.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Radical_Dreamer on September 11, 2005, 08:43:25 pm
Quote from: BlueThunder
I know you didn't say anything bad about Bush but he's delt with alot of tradgities.First 9/11 now Hurricane Katrinia,for all of that it makes him a good president.


The thing is, he didn't deal with Katrina, and that makes him a bad president.

Now for my story.

It was my senior year in high school. That year, my school started a policy by which seniors could only take 5 (instead of the usual 6) classes, if they had enough credits to graduate. I did, so, given my love of sleep and hatred of high school, I gave my self an extra hour of sleep by not taking a class second period*. This meant my sister, who is two years younger than me, went to school an hour earlier than I did.

On the fatefull morning, my mother came into my room and woke me up. She explained to me, very calmly, what had happened. By this time, both of the towers had been destroyed. I should mention at this point, that both of my parents are from New York City. We have a lot of friends and family in that town, all of whom escaped injury that day. I was then enformed that I'd be going to school to pick up my sister and bring her home, because we were staying home that day, just in case there were any attacks planned against Los Angeles.

After retrieving my sister, we spent the day at home, and a good portion of it in front of the television, watching the news. I knew that it would be my generation's J.F.K. assissination so to speak: everyone would remember where they were when they heard of the first attack on American soil since World War II.

*At my school, there were periods 1-8. Most people took a 2-7, but 3-8 were not horribly uncommon. Period 1 were mostly classes you could take during summer school or if you needed to make something up.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2005, 08:53:41 pm
Quote from: Radical_Dreamer
The thing is, he didn't deal with Katrina, and that makes him a bad president.


Yes he did, he has sent out rescue planes, food, water, everything! It is the survivors who are bad. Shooting at everything they can see. If you ask me, they shouldn't get help with the way they act.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 11, 2005, 08:56:05 pm
Quote from: nightmare975
Quote from: Radical_Dreamer
The thing is, he didn't deal with Katrina, and that makes him a bad president.


Yes he did, he has sent out rescue planes, food, water, everything! It is the survivors who are bad. Shooting at everything they can see. If you ask me, they shouldn't get help with the way they act.


Now now, lets not use that broad a brush...
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2005, 09:12:08 pm
Quote from: Sentenal
Quote from: nightmare975
Quote from: Radical_Dreamer
The thing is, he didn't deal with Katrina, and that makes him a bad president.


Yes he did, he has sent out rescue planes, food, water, everything! It is the survivors who are bad. Shooting at everything they can see. If you ask me, they shouldn't get help with the way they act.


Now now, lets not use that broad a brush...

I don't think nightmare975 was being serious. No one would prop up Bush at the expense of the disaster survivors.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2005, 09:13:45 pm
Quote from: Lord J esq
Quote from: Sentenal
Quote from: nightmare975
Quote from: Radical_Dreamer
The thing is, he didn't deal with Katrina, and that makes him a bad president.


Yes he did, he has sent out rescue planes, food, water, everything! It is the survivors who are bad. Shooting at everything they can see. If you ask me, they shouldn't get help with the way they act.


Now now, lets not use that broad a brush...

I don't think nightmare975 was being serious. No one would prop up Bush at the expense of the disaster survivors.


You know what makes it worse? People blaming Bush for the Hurricane!
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2005, 09:16:06 pm
Well, Bush didn't cause the hurricane itself. That much is obvious. But he caused the second disaster, and is responsible for most of the deaths that occured in New Orleans in particular, and for some of the deaths in the rest of the region.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 11, 2005, 09:18:06 pm
What, the leevies breaking?  I didn't realize he stapped C4 on them and blew them up...  Or are you talking about the lawless-ness?  Ain't his fault there either.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Silvercry on September 11, 2005, 09:21:56 pm
Quote from: Lord J esq
Well, Bush didn't cause the hurricane itself. That much is obvious. But he caused the second disaster, and is responsible for most of the deaths that occured in New Orleans in particular, and for some of the deaths in the rest of the region.


And how is that exactly? Save for the creation of the Department of Homeland security, which tied up FEMA's hands with added red tape, I mean.  That much obvious.  Of course, had both organizations shown a little foresight (they did have a week or warning after all) even that wouldn’t have delayed aid as much as it did.  And the super ‘we can take a cat-5 hurricane!!!!!11111oneone’ levies breaking AFTER the hurricane was gone didn’t help either.

Bush is guilty of plenty.  He doesn’t need manufactured wrong-doing as well.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 11, 2005, 09:25:46 pm
It was a cat. 1 storm until a few days before it hit.  Blame rests on the local/state government.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2005, 09:30:51 pm
Quote from: Sentenal
What, the leevies breaking?  I didn't realize he stapped C4 on them and blew them up...  Or are you talking about the lawless-ness?  Ain't his fault there either.

The Bush administration systematically cut funding for levee and floodwall upgrades in New Orleans due to the incredible expense of the Iraq war and the soaring deficits his administration had built up. Bush also diverted Army Corps of Engineers resources away from the effort and into Iraq.

Very much his criminal liability is of two prongs. The first prong is his administration's failure to prevent the floodwalls from having failed in the first place. If that money had been spent, New Orleans would not have sunk.

The second prong, of course, is his bungled administration of the federal response once the disaster had occured. This resulted in a much higher loss of life.

Quote from: Silvercry
Save for the creation of the Department of Homeland security, which tied up FEMA's hands with added red tape, I mean.  That much obvious.  Of course, had both organizations shown a little foresight (they did have a week or warning after all) even that wouldn’t have delayed aid as much as it did.  And the super ‘we can take a cat-5 hurricane!!!!!11111oneone’ levies breaking AFTER the hurricane was gone didn’t help either.

Your understanding of the facts is incomplete at best. FEMA was neutered during the Bush administration; its entire upper ranks were given to people who had little or no experience in managing disasters.

Your bit about the levees is incoherent...I'm not sure what you're trying to say.

Quote from: Silvercry
Bush is guilty of plenty.  He doesn’t need manufactured wrong-doing as well.

In this case, Bush and some of his staff are guilty of criminal neglect and manslaughter en masse. I personally rank it as a crime against humanity as stipulated under international law.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Silvercry on September 11, 2005, 09:34:30 pm
Quote from: Sentenal
It was a cat. 1 storm until a few days before it hit.  Blame rests on the local/state government.


True.  A lot of people forget that fact, as well as the fact that it crossed over Florida with nowhere never that level devastation before it entered the gulf of Mexico.  It blew up in the gulf, in size and power, going from “just another Ivan,” into a “Betsy Part II: This Time Its Personal”

A lot could have been done that wasn’t done to save lives in the aftermath.  But blaming Bush just because it’s in style these days accomplishes nothing when it’s not his fault.  I’m no fan of Bush, but I believe in giving credit when credit is due.  And this one isn’t his fault.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2005, 09:41:30 pm
Please see the thread I have just created to continue this off-topic discussion. Thanks.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: AuraTwilight on September 11, 2005, 09:44:29 pm
I didn't lose anyone in the attack. I'm asian. So...um....I hope you guys get reimbursed for your two little towers. Your little book trilogy will live on. Anyway, as for the Katrina discussion...

Quote
Blame rests on the local/state government.


Exactly. What would he have done? People overestimate the power of the president. He's not omniscient of every problem in America, nor does he have the authority to deal with everything. He can only do what the Senate allows him to do, and then the Supreme Court has to approve it.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 12, 2005, 12:14:55 am
Quote
The Bush administration systematically cut funding for levee and floodwall upgrades in New Orleans due to the incredible expense of the Iraq war and the soaring deficits his administration had built up. Bush also diverted Army Corps of Engineers resources away from the effort and into Iraq.


*sigh*

Take a look here: http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2005/09/0902_050902_katrina_levees_2.html

Specifically, this:
Quote
Until the day before Katrina's arrival, New Orleans's 350 miles (560 kilometers) of levees were undergoing a feasibility study to examine the possibility of upgrading them to withstand a Category Four or Five storm.
Corps officials say the study, which began in 2000, will take several years to complete.

Upgrading the system would take as long as 20 to 25 years, according to Al Naomi, the Corps' senior project manager for the New Orleans District.


Basically, here it is.  Did Bush cut the funding?  Yes.  Did it make a difference?  No.  It would take a few years for the study, which would bring it to about 2002-2004 for the study completion, then add the 20-25 years to actually do something.

So in short: No, the funding cut didn't affect it.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 12, 2005, 12:37:10 am
Quote from: Sentenal
Basically, here it is.  Did Bush cut the funding?  Yes.  Did it make a difference?  No.  It would take a few years for the study, which would bring it to about 2002-2004 for the study completion, then add the 20-25 years to actually do something.

So in short: No, the funding cut didn't affect it.

The floodwalls which breached, did so as the result of overflow waters that then eroded the ground underneath these walls. This danger was understood before the study you mention.

The failure here is that, prior to the hurricane actually happening, the probability of such a storm as Katrina was so low that there was no political willpower to divert monies for improving the floodwalls. Would this have been different under a Democratic administration and Congress? I don't know; but I do know that politicians who ignore dangers because of their statistical improbability, and then get stuck out in the rain when those dangers come to pass, deserve to be held responsible for failing to use their resources more wisely. Bush decided national disaster preparedness wasn't important, and now I and every other patriotic citizen is going to rake him across the coals for it. We have seen once and for all the result of four years of his administration's attempts to make this nation better able to cope with an emergency.

Let's be honest. If everything about this situation were the same, except that it was a Democrat in the White House and Republicans on the state and local level, you'd be blaming the man in Washington. That's the difference between us. I'd be blaming the guilty party; you're looking to blame liberals. The fact that Bush is at fault for this, rather than a liberal, is just one more incentive for me to prosecute the case against him with that much more zeal. I also understand that state officials bear some responsibility. Primarily, their guilt has to do with the lack of proper coordination. And the governor and senior senator are Democrats. Well, tough. They're in trouble too.

But the lion's share of this disaster is Bush's fault, and do not think that we're going to let you conservatives forget it. The dangers of floodwall collapse were known years in advance--decades, really--and the funding for improving those weaknesses could have been made available many years ago, rather than being cut.

Maybe or maybe not it would have made a difference in time for Katrina to strike...but it would have been the correct effort, and it would have relieved this administration of a big slice of its guilt.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Hadriel on September 12, 2005, 12:43:00 am
Quote from: Lord J esq
Let's be honest. If everything about this situation were the same, except that it was a Democrat in the White House and Republicans on the state and local level, you'd be blaming the man in Washington. That's the difference between us. I'd be blaming the guilty party; you're looking to blame liberals.


That's an assumption; not at all an unfounded one, but still an assumption.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Sentenal on September 12, 2005, 12:48:08 am
Quote
Let's be honest. If everything about this situation were the same, except that it was a Democrat in the White House and Republicans on the state and local level, you'd be blaming the man in Washington. That's the difference between us. I'd be blaming the guilty party; you're looking to blame liberals.


Eh, no.  In this situtation, I'm blaming State/Local government.  I'd probably still blame them if Kerry was in office.  I'm not sure why you think your immune to being completely non-partisan, but I'm not.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 12, 2005, 01:09:14 am
Quote from: Hadriel
Quote from: Lord J esq
Let's be honest. If everything about this situation were the same, except that it was a Democrat in the White House and Republicans on the state and local level, you'd be blaming the man in Washington. That's the difference between us. I'd be blaming the guilty party; you're looking to blame liberals.


That's an assumption; not at all an unfounded one, but still an assumption.

An assumption, aye, but one based on my colorful exchanges with Sentenal. I know where he stands, and he's even more to the right than I am to the left...passion recognizes passion, indubitably.

Quote from: Sentenal
Quote
Let's be honest. If everything about this situation were the same, except that it was a Democrat in the White House and Republicans on the state and local level, you'd be blaming the man in Washington. That's the difference between us. I'd be blaming the guilty party; you're looking to blame liberals.


Eh, no.  In this situtation, I'm blaming State/Local government.  I'd probably still blame them if Kerry was in office.  I'm not sure why you think your immune to being completely non-partisan, but I'm not.

Well, I'm hardly exempt. I said as much in my last post; when conservatives fuck up I'm going to pounce on them harder than I would if they were liberals.

But as to your substantive point, that you are blaming the state and local officials rather than the federal ones, there is a good case against your logic in the other thread I've made on this board. But it all boils down to this:

Local Government: Responsible for evacuating the city prior to the storm
The City of New Orleans did issue a mandatory evacuation, but failed to help its least mobile citizens evacuate. Furthermore, the evacuation order was given one day later than most other municipalities in the at-risk region. Nevertheless, this is the extent of the local governments' culpability. Once the storm struck, all affected local authorities were overwhelmed and cannot have been expected to function. This was foreseen and should have been provided for in a rational disaster response plan. No local authority, in New Orleans or elsewhere, should be held responsible for the disaster response to a major hurricane.

State Government: Responsible for coordinating the disaster response and supplying personnel and equipment for that response
The governors of Louisiana and Mississippi knew they were in for a big hit, which is why they declared states of emergency preemptively and got the president to do the same. They understood that their state resources were likely to be overwhelmed by the sheer enormity of the storm, and appealed to the federal government for help. Nevertheless, absent that help, they still should have engaged a disaster response plan and put their own state resources on standby. They should have coordinated the initial phases of the response, in the event federal help had not arrived, and coped with the emergency as best they could. Of course, this did not happen. Louisiana and Mississippi, both poor states, had little or no disaster response coordination. They bungled every aspect of this. It was bad in Alabama too, and even in other states, where the storm's weakening strength relieved them of their onus. The state officials, particularly in LA and MS, are responsible for not having had a functional state-level disaster response plan in place, or, if such a plan existed, not having implemented it with any success or indication of top-level oversight and intercommunication.

Federal Government: Responsible for providing relief of a greater magnitude but similar nature to that of the state authorities
The reason the federal government is guilty is fourfold: First, FEMA had been gutted by the Bush administration, and was utterly inept in responding to the disaster. Second, the military was unable to proceed into an active disaster response role without the president's order, which was days in coming after the disaster had already struck. Third, the federal government failed to swiftly process the paperwork necessary to allow National Guard units from other states to be deployed to the affected areas. Fourth, the president himself showed little indication that he grasped the magnitude of the disaster until half a week after Katrina had hit. He failed to use his extraordinary executive powers--all of which had been legally there for him to use, had he wanted to--to bypass a great deal of the federal bureaucracy and get in there to do the jobs that the states were bungling. Indeed, the feds bungled even worse than the state officials did. Once again it was our spectacular military that ultimately came to the rescue, the only institution with the expertise and equipment to deal with this disaster that Bush hasn't yet decimated. But by the time things started running smoothly, nearly a week had gone by since Katrina struck, and hundreds if not thousands of people were dead.

The two lower levels of government correctly realized that they were overwhelmed by the magnitude of the storm and, in New Orleans, the floodwall breaches, and they appealed to the federal government for help. The federal government did not provide this help in a timely fashion. Therein lies a major slice of its culpability, and President Bush's in particular.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: V_Translanka on September 12, 2005, 07:25:22 am
The events of that day and it's effects which lasted for...well, I guess forever...well, they just plain pissed me off. No, not because I lost anyone in any of the plane crashes. Heck, not even because I cared a whole bunch about those people dying (I don't like people in general and my philosophy is the more dead the better, no offense intended for anyone who happens to like people), but it was awful weird to see...I was just like, "Whoa." Like Keanu Reeves style...but anyways...It made me angry because on the following Wednesday, the news was still blitzing everyone w/the War on Terror & Terror In America & TERROR TERROR BE AFRAID OF THE TERRORISTS (oogity boo!) that the new episode of Family Guy was completely lost to me. :cry: And it didn't come back either...Well, until it went over to Cartoon Network...and then, what? TNN? TNT? One of those crappy networks that nobody really watches...and now it's back on FOX too...Or maybe it started syndicating on TNN/TNT/whatever after it came back to FOX...I don't remember...

But it was a sad day indeed when the news overshadowed Family Guy...especially when it was really never new news after the first or second day...Oh well...At least Family Guy is back...I think we can all sit back and rejoice that the Terrorists completely failed in their mediocre attempt to sabotoge Family Guy. BWAH HAHA! I say to you Terrorists! Not only did you fail, but it's syndicating on two OTHER networks now! Take that! Go America! Whoohoo! etc.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Zaperking on September 12, 2005, 09:49:36 am
I was in grade 4 back then. We came to school and my teacher had everyone sit in a circle and take turns expressing their emotions. I didn't get why. It's not like it affected me anyway >.> But people die, very sad. The only bad thing was that the news made the deaths seem like a statistic and less of tragedy. Besides the point that Bush is a moron. So many conspiracies.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 12, 2005, 10:10:28 pm
You know, I'm just glad that everybody didn't lose anybody in the attack.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Kazuki on September 13, 2005, 12:04:47 am
Quote from: nightmare975
You know, I'm just glad that everybody didn't lose anybody in the attack.


This contradicts what you say in the thread, "Great President Bush", but I agree. We who were lucky should be grateful that we are this fortunate.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 13, 2005, 12:08:30 am
Quote from: Kazuki
Quote from: nightmare975
You know, I'm just glad that everybody didn't lose anybody in the attack.


This contradicts what you say in the thread, "Great President Bush", but I agree. We who were lucky should be grateful that we are this fortunate.


Those are two different things, the victims of 9/11 didn't shoot at the fire fighters who were trying to rescue them.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: SilentMartyr on September 14, 2005, 05:48:33 pm
I'd just like to say to Aura, comments like yours make me glad that we dropped two nukes on you guys.

I was a senior in high school at the time. I was in study hall (grades were not good enough to be able to skip), and a student came in and told the teacher that a plane had hit the WTC. In the A/V room they had a TV set up to CBS news and any students that were not in class could watch. Our teacher allowed us to go watch, and minutes later I saw the second plane hit. That was something, in one instant all I could think about was WAR. It was like this big gigantic slap in the face. The Pentagon hit was worrysome but nothing of too much dispair, that place is rock solid so I knew that not much was really damaged, the real deal was levels below.

My next class was calculus, and our teacher allowed us to watch some more, and I saw both towers collaspe in that time. At first, the planes really didn't make me think of death, but when the buildings fell I knew that this was going to take a grand number of people. My one friend placed her head on my shoulder when the first tower came down, we both knew the toll it would bring.

I myself didn't lose anyone, but a classmate of mines uncle worked in tower one. He didn't make it to work that day however, due to a fallen tree in his driveway. If I was him I would have bought a lottery ticket that day, but thats just me.

I agree with that attack on Afghanistan, that needed to happen. But Iraq, just no. And definetely not before Afghanistan was completely done with. We should have made sure that the country was stable before going after phantom weapons and dictators who were not involved.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 14, 2005, 06:12:15 pm
Quote from: SilentMartyr
I'd just like to say to Aura, comments like yours make me glad that we dropped two nukes on you guys.

The rest of your post is well-taken, but this part is out of line. Indeed, you are doing the very thing for which you criticize Aura.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: Hadriel on September 14, 2005, 06:19:51 pm
Quote from: SilentMartyr
I'd just like to say to Aura, comments like yours make me glad that we dropped two nukes on you guys.


OH SNAP CATFIGHT

You know what's funny to me?  I was in band at the time, and we were playing a piece from Japan.  When I thought about it later I lol'd.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: SilentMartyr on September 15, 2005, 04:30:12 pm
Quote from: Lord J esq
Quote from: SilentMartyr
I'd just like to say to Aura, comments like yours make me glad that we dropped two nukes on you guys.

The rest of your post is well-taken, but this part is out of line. Indeed, you are doing the very thing for which you criticize Aura.


I know, that was the point of the line. Sometimes they only learn by mirroring. He probably won't but its always worth a shot.
Title: Never Forget...
Post by: V_Translanka on September 15, 2005, 06:02:37 pm
It's never worth a shot and you know it (unless it's hysterically funny, that is). Go to your shame corner!

:lol: Oh man, I totally couldn't decide whether it should be a shame corner or a shame hole...
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 10, 2006, 01:47:54 pm
Bumping this back up for September 11th tomorrow.

Same question as before, mostly directed to the new members.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Magus22 on September 10, 2006, 07:50:16 pm
Since the anniversary is tomorrow, why doesn't everyone post where they were and when they heard about it?

I was in 8th grade in the lunch room when everyone overheard what had happened on the PA. At my last block class for the end of the day (Social Studies) we watched CNN and about 100 replays of the planes crashing into the two towers. I was so angry afterwards, like the days after. I didn't really care that much about the whole situation, mainly because I can block out stuff like that pretty well. It doesn't affect me until I really start thinking about it. I will sometimes try and laugh it off or play video games and to focus my mind on something else.

Anywho, from then on and since last Thanksgiving, I was all hard core about joining the Marine Corps and making a difference. Luckily, I didn't sign and papers and I pulled away from the whole military business. Damn shame really . . . all the while since 8th grade I told everyone and made it clear that I was going to find Bin Laden in some cave or shoot some towel heads (no offense).

I am glad I did not take that path because I would still be at Parris Island, SC right now for recruit training. I am also glad that I am continuing my education locally at a college and most of all, I am with my family. I don't think I could do the whole "live on campus" thing even though I would be probably be learning a lot . . . since I'd be away from the parents and only be with people my age for quite some time. I heard that living on campus is the continuing factor of shaping someone after high school. I am most likely dead wrong though.

Anyone else like to share?
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: ZeaLitY on September 10, 2006, 08:33:03 pm
Good call. You can be more of a difference by becoming a productive, intelligent, and aspiring member of society than catching bullets.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Burning Zeppelin on September 11, 2006, 04:18:09 am
Is tommorrow Tuesday or Monday in America?

Well, I was sleeping when it happened. It was late at night, or really early morning, whatever floats yo' boat, and my dad called from work to tell my mum that "the world is ending" or something like that. My mum woke me up (can't remember about sis) and we watched it on the news. It was pretty horrific at the time, but now as I've grown older, it is just so much more.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Magus068 on September 11, 2006, 05:43:01 am
Today is aniversary of 9/11 of which the day that the WTC falls & hundreds of people died... We must keep our guard up so that the 9/11 tragedy will never happen again.  I pray for those who died in 9/11 tragedy & may their soul rest in peace...
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Daniel Krispin on September 11, 2006, 04:40:03 pm
I have always thought, and will always think, it was overhyped. A hundred thousand evils have happened in the world, even in recent times, that far outmatch this. It is merely given inordinate focus. Four thousand dead? The families have a reason to grieve, to be sure, but what is it to everyone else? If that sort of event is enough to shake a nation as large as the United States, then they are truly weak. Four thousand is not a huge number of casualties. Most battlefields have a worse showing, even in ancient times. How many died at Canae? 60 to 80 thousand, about 80% of those being Roman troops? Yet what did the Romans do? They didn't get disheartened. They kept fighting. The US has, as always, shown itself to be a strong nation with a weak heart.

People say 'let us never forget', and, well, maybe it's because I'm Canadian, but it doesn't give me cause for grieving in the least. We live in a harsh world, we suffer what we must. And four thousand lives ended is less than died on the average day during the second world war. What makes this so great? Because the supposed superpowers of the world were, for a day, beaten? Do we weep because of that, or do we continue onward? People must move on, and not dwell in the past. Those who were directly affected, let them grieve (but even for them, grief must have its due range and compass, and not last inordinate length.) But for me, I have yet to be shown why it was such a dire catastrophe. It is a war, and things like that happen in a war. The Israelis and the Palestinians have to put up with that all the time.

I'm just being a realist here. I disdain inordinate grieving, and value a more stoic approach to life. People who put no term to grieving have no future.

As a side-note, the event was not a tragedy. It was an event of strong emotion, of loss and disaster. But tragedy requires a certain depth of spirit capable of suffering. It is, in fact, a glorious thing, because it shows the strength of the human spirit when confronted by hardship. All I've seen from the US since then is the very opposite.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Magus22 on September 11, 2006, 04:40:53 pm
Today is aniversary of 9/11 of which the day that the WTC falls & hundreds of people died... We must keep our guard up so that the 9/11 tragedy will never happen again.  I pray for those who died in 9/11 tragedy & may their soul rest in peace...

No doubt.

Thousands of people died. I doubt we'll get attacked again on home soil in along time.

I also missed a memorial service this morning at college... damn
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: but2002 on September 11, 2006, 05:24:18 pm
SOmething has got me wondering about the 9/11 thing anyway, A plane crashed into the Building right? Well if you look at the Video, the way the building went down looked way too controlled, It almost as if a plane never hit it, but one DID, so I think there was another part to the Destruction as well as the plane.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Daniel Krispin on September 11, 2006, 05:32:30 pm
SOmething has got me wondering about the 9/11 thing anyway, A plane crashed into the Building right? Well if you look at the Video, the way the building went down looked way too controlled, It almost as if a plane never hit it, but one DID, so I think there was another part to the Destruction as well as the plane.

Okayee, here we go. I'll see what I can remember. I was trained as a MecE, not a CivE, but when that all happened I was in first year, and had a class about structures. That day the prof came in and explained why the buildings fell.

Firstly, it must be pointed out, they were extremely well designed. They got hit by planes full of jet fuel, and still remained standing for hours - that is an engineering marvel. But, let's see if I can describe this... the way the buildings were designed is roughtly so, if I remember: main support structures running the entire height of the building. Now, beams that tall will of course bend and break, right? What kept that from happening were the floors themselves. The floors checked at each story the outward bending tendancy of the support columns, thus making a coherent and stable structure. However, the impact of the plane did two things. Firstly, it destroyed a heck of a lot of floors, leaving an area of the beams several stories high that had no check to its bending. This wouldn't have been too much of a problem nearer the top, but where they hit there was sufficient weight from above to pose a danger. Even this, though was not enough to destroy the buildings. What truly did them in was the jet fuel and the fires they caused. This heated the support beams, and weakened them to the point where they bent under the weight from above. When they snapped, you had essentially several stories collapsing in on themeselves, bringing all the rest from above crashing down. Now keep in mind that all the structure here is a very tight thing - the rest of the support beams still keep the upper and lower segments tied together, likely even as they are crashing down upon each other. That likely accounts for what you saw, and why it did not fall outward or crumble away as you might have otherwise expected. It was not controlled, per say, but rather extremely well built, to the very end. The fall was essentially vertical, therefore, from what I can remember.

Somebody correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that's how it happened.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2006, 09:44:40 pm
The thing about the beams overheating could of been prevented if they had laced the beams with asbestos. I heard that from my science teacher once.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Daniel Krispin on September 11, 2006, 09:52:09 pm
The thing about the beams overheating could of been prevented if they had laced the beams with asbestos. I heard that from my science teacher once.

That does make sense. Aspestos being a heat-shielding material, it would have slowed the weakening effect of the fire, thus preserving the support pillars. However, aspestos is rarely used these days because it is a dangerous material. Skyscrapers were never meant to be hit by planes, either. There is no way something like that could have been expected in the design of the structures. A normal fire wouldn't have caused the same problem, you see. No one sitting around the drawing board would have figured to account for the twofold destruction of a great portion of several stories, an explosion, and a fire, all at once. I figure whoever designed those buildings did an extraordiary job, even allowing them to stand as long as they did.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: but2002 on September 11, 2006, 11:22:07 pm
:P You right, I looked it up after I said that, and I saw my answer there. Thanks for pointhing it out though ^^
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: ZeaLitY on September 12, 2006, 12:12:55 am
The thing about the beams overheating could of been prevented if they had laced the beams with asbestos. I heard that from my science teacher once.

The problem is that asbestos causes lung cancer. It would have to be non-friable, but even then the plane's impact would have shot asbestos into the air all over New York City. That would be a massive catastrophe. There's a reason asbestos litigation is the longest, most expensive mass tort in U.S. history, involving more than 6,000 defendants and 600,000 claimants.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Burning Zeppelin on September 12, 2006, 04:39:18 am
It was pretty overhyped. I mean, more people died in the massacre of the Native Americans than this.
But yes, it was horrible.

One point my sister pointed (duh) out was that America likes making wars on verbs and nouns, like War on Drugs, War on Terror, and War on Spontaneous Combustion.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: ZeaLitY on September 12, 2006, 09:19:58 am
The Daily Show is pretty good at ridiculing that rhetoric. Just as GW says we're "safe" but not "Safe," Liberals are calling themselves Progressives now since Kerry stained the term by losing the election.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: V_Translanka on September 12, 2006, 06:02:28 pm
One point my sister pointed (duh) out was that America likes making wars on verbs and nouns, like War on Drugs, War on Terror, and War on Spontaneous Combustion.

And here, I'm pointing out (duy) that your sister is retarded. What else are they going to war against? Adverbs? Conjunctions? Verbs and nouns are the basis of the English language. Hit your sister upside the head once for me, would you?
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Daniel Krispin on September 12, 2006, 06:43:38 pm
One point my sister pointed (duh) out was that America likes making wars on verbs and nouns, like War on Drugs, War on Terror, and War on Spontaneous Combustion.

And here, I'm pointing out (duy) that your sister is retarded. What else are they going to war against? Adverbs? Conjunctions? Verbs and nouns are the basis of the English language. Hit your sister upside the head once for me, would you?

Participles, maybe? You could have 'the war against running' for example.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: V_Translanka on September 12, 2006, 08:08:48 pm
Oh, that's just an offshoot of a verb and you know it!

<~*(irreverent)POST 3000*~>
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Burning Zeppelin on September 13, 2006, 04:33:59 am
One point my sister pointed (duh) out was that America likes making wars on verbs and nouns, like War on Drugs, War on Terror, and War on Spontaneous Combustion.

And here, I'm pointing out (duy) that your sister is retarded. What else are they going to war against? Adverbs? Conjunctions? Verbs and nouns are the basis of the English language. Hit your sister upside the head once for me, would you?
Done and done.
How 'bout proper nouns?
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: V_Translanka on September 13, 2006, 05:38:40 pm
The proper noun is just a specific type of noun...It's still a noun...
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 13, 2006, 10:00:24 pm
Locking the topic until next year.

And remember that we should never forget...
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2007, 12:18:29 am
Well, seeing as tomorrow is 9/11, I'm opening this back up early (I have school tomorrow, so I'd be opening this up around the same time >_<).

Another year and it seems like nothing has changed. We're still in Iraq, the country is going downhill and America still hates Bush with a burning passion.

Your views of the past year?
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: ZeaLitY on September 11, 2007, 12:25:17 am
(http://grove.ufl.edu/~locutus/Pic/Bttf2/newspaper2.jpg)

We are in bad 1985.

(http://i56.photobucket.com/albums/g189/eahennin/urbanBiff_1985-A.jpg)

A worse version of Biff is running things.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Flynn on September 11, 2007, 12:28:23 am
(http://grove.ufl.edu/~locutus/Pic/Bttf2/newspaper2.jpg)

We are in bad 1985.

(http://i56.photobucket.com/albums/g189/eahennin/urbanBiff_1985-A.jpg)

A worse version of Biff is running things.

I love the analogy using the Alternate 1985. I'm not sure if it's that horrendous, but . . . we could be well on our way if things don't change.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Magus22 on September 11, 2007, 01:21:42 am
Well, quite a change since my last log on.

I can't believe it has been 6 years now. So has anyone heard the latest? Al-Qaeda's new targets are going to be grammar schools in the U.S.

Splendid. They still haven't had enough yet. Bin Laden wants us infidels to convert to Islamn as well. Revenge is a dish best served cold, eh?
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Kyronea on September 11, 2007, 05:52:08 am

An uncertain future, definitely. That is the legacy of September 11. I lost no family, no friends, but perhaps I lost my country.
This may have been written two years ago, J, but that was absolutely amazing...I was moved, yes I was.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: maggiekarp on September 11, 2007, 12:20:12 pm
Are 9/11 jokes okay yet?
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: grey_the_angel on September 11, 2007, 03:40:51 pm
as rude as this may sound, I wanna forget. Just like I wanna forget about princess Diana. and here's the reason: this  isn't honoring the memory at this point, it's martyring a bunch of people to rally across some otherwise really stupid notion.
"OMG TERRORIST DID 9/11 NEVER FARGET THIS BE THE REASON WE IN IRAQ!" frankly, I don't wanna be reminded alot of people died because 11 random idiots from the middle east did slightly more damage then one white boy with a bomb did in Oklahoma, an event NO ONE bothers to remember.

As for princess Diana: IT YOUR FUCKING FAULT SHE'S DEAD, ENTERTAINMENT IDUSTRY, SHUT THE FUCK UP AND STOP WHORING OUT HER FUCKING NAME FOR RATINGS.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: FaustWolf on September 11, 2007, 04:14:10 pm
I dunno, grey, I've always thought it's important to hold onto Sept. 11 precisely because it serves as a reminder of how idiotic all human conflict is -- along with Hiroshima & Nagasaki, the Holocaust, etc., etc. I've never seen any propaganda value in it whatsoever (though our illustrious President no doubt does, as you've pointed out). If anything, it reminds me of just how wrong the whole US strategy in the War on Terror is.

Oh, and maggie, I'm not sure about 9/11 jokes, but Marle x Magus comics are always okay.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2007, 05:05:22 pm
Hey gray, it's your opinion, I really don't care. I just unlock this every year so we don't get 100 topics about 9/11.

Oh, and jews did 9/11.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Kyronea on September 11, 2007, 05:50:02 pm
No, Semites did.

And Grey, it was nineteen, not eleven.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2007, 06:00:13 pm
No, Semites did.

You haven't been to YTMND I presume?
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Kyronea on September 11, 2007, 06:07:58 pm


You haven't been to YTMND I presume?
I've been to it...I once thought it funny, before I realized just how much of it is hateful racism, homophobia, sexism, and the like. It's disgusting.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: grey_the_angel on September 11, 2007, 06:16:21 pm
No, Semites did.

And Grey, it was nineteen, not eleven.
sorry. 19 idiots.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: ZeaLitY on September 11, 2007, 07:05:48 pm
This world is populated by cretins. Sadly, some of them vote. Worse, some of them get involved in the media. My college newspaper contains an article about how we've "forgotten" 9/11 and how come politics is all BS and why can't Republicans and Democrats become united and say the Pledge with pride and why can't America just do like Pearl Harbor and unite against the enemy and win quickly, etc.

I fucking trashed that paper. I could have put it back on the newsstand, but god forbid someone else read this naive child's ignorant rantings.

This commentary is to be expected on 9/11.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2007, 07:36:02 pm


You haven't been to YTMND I presume?
I've been to it...I once thought it funny, before I realized just how much of it is hateful racism, homophobia, sexism, and the like. It's disgusting.

Eh, you have to have a tough skin to remain on that site.

And Zeality, just remember that as long as you keep that attitude, the terrorists will never win. :P
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 12, 2007, 12:18:40 am
Six years, now. And on a Tuesday, too. I still remember large swaths of that day.

Since then, I am sad to say that Osama bin Laden has succeeded far more wildly than he had any right to hope for. As every intelligent terrorist knows, the secret to success is to turn the enemy's own power against them. And that is exactly what has happened. The American people live in constant fear of another attack; large swaths of the us are eager to give up whatever liberties it takes to achieve the illusion of safety; so many of us have forgotten the meaning of justice in our fervent support for torture and preemptive war; we have alienated ourselves from our allies; we have invaded a country and destroyed it--with no plan for reconstruction--leading to the deaths of hundreds of thousands of innocent people; we have squandered away our economic vitality; we have given Islamic terrorism a jolt of life that will last throughout the century; all the while failing to protect our ports and borders; failing to set an unmistakable standard of leadership that all the world could follow; failing to champion and achieve liberty in the country whose most sacred word is liberty. And, for all these wounds we have inflicted upon ourselves, upon our friends, and upon the defenseless, we have not even caught the man who attacked us six years ago today. He sits in a cave, impervious to all American might, making movies.

Is there anything good that has come of all this? Can anybody name a single thing that we have done right?
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 12, 2007, 12:25:22 am
We took down an evil tyrant. Even though it had nothing to do about 9-11.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: ZeaLitY on September 12, 2007, 12:25:34 am
With any luck, we've set a horrible precedent which all future generations will be mindful to never follow or emulate.

Well, you can think that, but then you remember red states...
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 12, 2007, 12:30:13 am
We took down an evil tyrant. Even though it had nothing to do about 9-11.

You're right, of course. But this is the very essence of a "Pyrrhic victory." At this point it isn't even controversial anymore to point out that the Iraqi people were better off under Saddam.

Nevertheless, I asked for some good, and, sure enough, there it is. Heh. Got any "untarnished" good?
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Daniel Krispin on September 12, 2007, 02:01:24 am
We took down an evil tyrant. Even though it had nothing to do about 9-11.

You're right, of course. But this is the very essence of a "Pyrrhic victory." At this point it isn't even controversial anymore to point out that the Iraqi people were better off under Saddam.

Nevertheless, I asked for some good, and, sure enough, there it is. Heh. Got any "untarnished" good?

Canada's economy relative to the US is way better. Our dollar is what now, 95c to the American? Before the war it was something like 64. That's a bonus. Oh, wait, that's only good for Canadians.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Radical_Dreamer on September 12, 2007, 03:34:17 am
We took down an evil tyrant. Even though it had nothing to do about 9-11.

You're right, of course. But this is the very essence of a "Pyrrhic victory." At this point it isn't even controversial anymore to point out that the Iraqi people were better off under Saddam.

Nevertheless, I asked for some good, and, sure enough, there it is. Heh. Got any "untarnished" good?

Canada's economy relative to the US is way better. Our dollar is what now, 95c to the American? Before the war it was something like 64. That's a bonus. Oh, wait, that's only good for Canadians.

Yeah, it's in that range. Still not worth it to cash in that last twoney in my wallet though.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Burning Zeppelin on September 12, 2007, 04:55:44 am
Sadly, some of them vote.
Heh, at least only some. Here, ALL of them vote.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: dan_death on September 12, 2007, 09:51:31 am
We took down an evil tyrant. Even though it had nothing to do about 9-11.

I believe the true tyrant is still alive. The true tyrant is Bush. And this video is what I think is really going through his head:

http://youtube.com/watch?v=DRdAikxq3mw

Even though at the end if it, it says it has no political message.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Kebrel on September 12, 2007, 09:53:17 pm
Six years, now. And on a Tuesday, too. I still remember large swaths of that day.

Since then, I am sad to say that Osama bin Laden has succeeded far more wildly than he had any right to hope for. As every intelligent terrorist knows, the secret to success is to turn the enemy's own power against them. And that is exactly what has happened. The American people live in constant fear of another attack; large swaths of the us are eager to give up whatever liberties it takes to achieve the illusion of safety; so many of us have forgotten the meaning of justice in our fervent support for torture and preemptive war; we have alienated ourselves from our allies; we have invaded a country and destroyed it--with no plan for reconstruction--leading to the deaths of hundreds of thousands of innocent people; we have squandered away our economic vitality; we have given Islamic terrorism a jolt of life that will last throughout the century; all the while failing to protect our ports and borders; failing to set an unmistakable standard of leadership that all the world could follow; failing to champion and achieve liberty in the country whose most sacred word is liberty. And, for all these wounds we have inflicted upon ourselves, upon our friends, and upon the defenseless, we have not even caught the man who attacked us six years ago today. He sits in a cave, impervious to all American might, making movies.

Is there anything good that has come of all this? Can anybody name a single thing that we have done right?

Fear not for in the year 1787 some random old guys came up with a backup plan, known as the 2nd Amendment it may have been hindered but its still there to use in that magical moment of healthy anarchy.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 12, 2007, 11:41:53 pm
Somehow I feel as though, if it were to come down to shooting at the government, we will have failed as a society! (Although that didn't pan out in the 1860s...)

But revolution might have its perks, I grant. I'd rather live in the great Liberal Utopia of Cascadia--California, Oregon, Washington, and British Columbia, all west of the Cascades and Sierras--than have to treat somebody from Pisswaffle, GA as a fellow citizen.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 12, 2007, 11:44:06 pm
Well, locking the topic again. We'll have to bring this back up next year.

And remember: Never Forget.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2008, 03:54:44 pm
Well, looks like September 11th has rolled on by again.

When I first created this thread in 2005, I had been a huge advocate of Bush. I hated to listen to people insult him and what not. But as I got older, I realized that most of them were right.

And 2009 marks the end of an era for us. For once, we will have a new president, but will they be able to tackle the problems left behind by Bush? Most likely. But will they bring with them their own problems? Most definitely.

And so now, I unlock this for you to pounce upon it like the savage barbarians you are, to express your views about a president we all know and loathe. [/sarcasm]
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: KebreI on September 11, 2008, 04:06:07 pm
Kids are such asses. A lot of my friends in High school are skipping today. They think its messed up its not a holiday, and they still have school. They claim to be remembering the attack when are just using this as an excuse to go out, absolutely sick. Then again some of then are skipping to mourn, they say its horrible that we get days of for dead presidents but not dead Americans!?! But none of then knew what happened on December 7th when asked.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2008, 05:05:06 pm
Put on “The Star Stealing Girl” from Chrono Cross and join me in a bit of reflection. It merits mention that, in the past seven years…

1.   We have failed to apprehend or kill the person most responsible for the attacks. In an apology for that disgraceful failure, many of the administration’s supporters have resorted to claiming that Osama bin Laden is no longer important. It is enough to make me wonder if these people believe anything they say.

2.   We lifted up Afghanistan from the clutches of right-wing religious theocracy, only to let it fade back into tribalism and Taliban theocracy due to our lack of attentiveness to the needs of the people there, our lack of understanding of their ways, our lack of real concern, and our refusal to commit enough money and manpower to make a difference.

3.   We have completely destroyed a nation, Iraq, and plunged those of its people who have not yet been slaughtered into a generation of terror, poverty, civil war, religious fanaticism, and the all the most horrific sexism of Islamic law as interpreted (and enforced) by young male radicals. In return for our efforts, we have gotten more of our own people killed than died on September 11 itself, and have amassed a fiscal debt that will not be repaid in the lifetimes of many Americans living today.

4.   Terrorism globally has risen and world political stability has waned, despite our nominal successes against al Qaeda in particular. America’s ability to prevent another terrorist attack on its own soil has been hindered by self-defeating policy, bureaucratic mismanagement, funding shortfalls, and a lack of real interest by the administration.

5.   We have lost the best portion of our standing and our power to check adversarial nations like Iran, Russia, Venezuela, Pakistan, Sudan, and others.

6.   Many of our quintessential American liberties, and a few essential democratic ones, have been nullified formally or for all practical purposes, in exchange for a false sense of security that will inevitably be exposed for the sham that it is, probably the hard way.

7.   The American people may remember the shock of being attacked, but have learned nothing from the experience, and have long since squandered any opportunity to better themselves in the aftermath of tragedy. Since that day, we have chosen to abandon our twentieth century leadership, and the unraveling of our superpower is underway. The terrorists probably could not have hoped for much better.

George Bush and his administration deserve much of the blame for the humiliating road we have taken in the past seven years, but the fact of the matter is that we let it happen. We voted this loser into office when such a superior alternative was available. We accepted his feeble logic and supported his conspicuously wretched policies when we should have known better. We reelected him when history gave us the chance to repent. And the truth of the matter is that, for as much as we despise him, we think a lot like he does.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: KebreI on September 11, 2008, 05:37:31 pm
Put on “The Star Stealing Girl” from Chrono Cross and join me in a bit of reflection. It merits mention that, in the past seven years…
I woke up to Departed Souls, this morning of all things.


Quote
1.   We have failed to apprehend or kill the person most responsible for the attacks. In an apology for that disgraceful failure, many of the administration’s supporters have resorted to claiming that Osama bin Laden is no longer important. It is enough to make me wonder if these people believe anything they say.
I don't think I have heard anything about "he's not important" from supporters.


Quote
2.   We lifted up Afghanistan from the clutches of right-wing religious theocracy, only to let it fade back into tribalism and Taliban theocracy due to our lack of attentiveness to the needs of the people there, our lack of understanding of their ways, our lack of real concern, and our refusal to commit enough money and manpower to make a difference.
I don't think thats in any way our fault, to be honest there culture for the most part is absolutely disgusting. We tried to change that, but its impossible for an outsider to do it. If they're to come out of there rut then it will be by their own hands. True for any culture.



Quote
3.   We have completely destroyed a nation, Iraq, and plunged those of its people who have not yet been slaughtered into a generation of terror, poverty, civil war, religious fanaticism, and the all the most horrific sexism of Islamic law as interpreted (and enforced) by young male radicals. In return for our efforts, we have gotten more of our own people killed than died on September 11 itself, and have amassed a fiscal debt that will not be repaid in the lifetimes of many Americans living today.
Same as above.


Quote
4.   Terrorism globally has risen and world political stability has waned, despite our nominal successes against al Qaeda in particular. America’s ability to prevent another terrorist attack on its own soil has been hindered by self-defeating policy, bureaucratic mismanagement, funding shortfalls, and a lack of real interest by the administration.
I blame not only America for this but a majority of the "Civil" world. There were to ways to stop terrorism, at our home or theirs. We tried to take it to theirs but were constantly held back but other countries choose home. Either would have worked but mix-matching policies doesn't.

Quote
5.   We have lost the best portion of our standing and our power to check adversarial nations like Iran, Russia, Venezuela, Pakistan, Sudan, and others.
I do agree with you there on a popularity level, but not in power. We can still take any of then out, thats just often more harm then good.


Quote
6.   Many of our quintessential American liberties, and a few essential democratic ones, have been nullified formally or for all practical purposes, in exchange for a false sense of security that will inevitably be exposed for the sham that it is, probably the hard way.
Quoted for truth.

Quote
7.   The American people may remember the shock of being attacked, but have learned nothing from the experience, and have long since squandered any opportunity to better themselves in the aftermath of tragedy. Since that day, we have chosen to abandon our twentieth century leadership, and the unraveling of our superpower is underway. The terrorists probably could not have hoped for much better.
No I think its not that we haven't learned its that we learned the wrong lesson. Now people instead of seeking out the problem hunting or conforming known Terrorist. The protect them selfs, they build walls and shun the outside. That just makes seeing an assassin all the more difficult.


Quote
George Bush and his administration deserve much of the blame for the humiliating road we have taken in the past seven years, but the fact of the matter is that we let it happen. We voted this loser into office when such a superior alternative was available. We accepted his feeble logic and supported his conspicuously wretched policies when we should have known better. We reelected him when history gave us the chance to repent. And the truth of the matter is that, for as much as we despise him, we think a lot like he does.
He is a pretty piss poor president yes, but I think people just like to blame the man in charge. The claim the could have done better that that pure crap. His a bad leader but hes still a better leader then most put him out to be.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2008, 09:30:16 pm
And J, we can never get out of our debt, it's near to impossible, Bush just made it more impossible.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Thought on September 12, 2008, 12:16:28 am
And J, we can never get out of our debt, it's near to impossible, Bush just made it more impossible.

Nothing is impossible, the will just has to be there first.

Unfortunately, no one has the will. It would be nice if that would change, however.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 12, 2008, 02:07:26 am
And J, we can never get out of our debt, it's near to impossible, Bush just made it more impossible.

Nothing is impossible, the will just has to be there first.

Unfortunately, no one has the will. It would be nice if that would change, however.

One of the only ways to get of the debt would be to raise taxes, which would be unthinkable. Unless someone has a better plan.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: KebreI on September 12, 2008, 02:11:39 am
Its funny our taxes are nothing compared to that of many other counties, my god look at France.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 12, 2008, 03:30:37 am
Its funny our taxes are nothing compared to that of many other counties, my god look at France.

That's because Americans refuse to pay taxes if they go too high, ignorant bastards.

A country needs to survive people!
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 12, 2008, 10:35:25 am
♪ Nothing's as scary as
--Anthrax is!
♪ Unless it's a budget
--Without taxes!
♪♪ You can't have it!
♪♪ You can't have it all!
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 12, 2008, 03:03:09 pm
♪ Unless it's a budget
--Without taxes!

One final note, I live in California, and we're still don't have a budget.

September 11th has come and gone once again. So yet again, I close this topic. Hopefully by this time next year, California will have a budget.

And remember: Never forget
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2009, 04:55:52 am
Hey look everyone, it's that time again.

:picardno9/11 NEVER FORGET! :picardno

Okay, Bush is gone, we got Obama, the world is starting to look a little brighter, right?

I'm not going to go that much into politics this year on the count that Obama hasn't done much to warrant a review yet.

Oh, and the Middle East is still fucked.

Once again, this topic is opened to everyone to discuss politics, bad memories, etc.

On September 12th the topic will be locked again.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Lord J Esq on September 11, 2009, 06:30:41 am
Aye, I admit I did think of September 11 all the way back on September 9, so it is still in my mind, but it feels "in the past" this year. That's the first time. I, for one, have moved on.

But you're right. We should not forget these moments of infamy in history...
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Lakonthegreat on September 11, 2009, 06:58:49 am
I still remember sitting in 8th grade taking an Algebra test and hearing the announcement on the intercom:

"Teachers, if you have a radio in your room, please tune it to 600 AM. A tragedy has occurred."

We all stopped what we were doing, started looking around at each other, and then we heard on the radio what happened. We looked at each other in disbelief. Literally, we could not grasp the fact that such a long-standing monument to consumerism had been destroyed. You saw them all the time in movies, and postcards and crap. Then you realize that there were people on almost every floor of the towers. That's when the crying started. One of our classmates had a broken family, and their dad worked in WTC2. Thankfully, he got out in time. This was a traumatizing day for all of us.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: ZombieBucky on September 11, 2009, 07:22:05 am
i remember that day. i was going to school. i remember looking outside the window in my english class. the sky was so perfectly blue. not a cloud dared to hide it.
and then they started having us have a bunch of moments of silence. i didnt know what was going on. were we honoring this beautiful day? but then i got home and my dad was like 'Matt something really bad happened today...'

i think my aunt was on one of those planes. theyre still looking for her.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: FaustWolf on September 11, 2009, 02:09:13 pm
Holy shit, Zombie. Are they still treating your aunt as a missing person then? Did you guys get a confirmation on her flight number that day?

Man, I was sitting in 11th grade chemistry class. The history teacher next door literally burst in shouting and ordered the chem teacher to turn on the TV.

What do you guys think of the war in Afghanistan nowadays? I get this sense that the media is treating it like another Vietnam (just like how they eventually treated the Iraq War to a considerable degree) but I'm glad the US has its "eye on the ball" again, so to speak. Now if we could stop killing Afghan civilians -- even on a strategic level, that's going to come back to bite us in the ass.

If any US military personnel (or any allied military personnel) are reading this, thank you for your service. We pacifists live in considerable luxury given that we have a choice...for the foreseeable future.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Truthordeal on September 11, 2009, 02:15:47 pm
I have to say, I do like this poll, simply because of all the "no's" it got. I'm glad most of us didn't have to go through that.

As far as I can tell, the current war in Afghanistan seems to be going...well, not terribly, but some oomph needs to be added. Civilian deaths are going to happen in any war. Its unfortunate, but the most we can hope for is that our troops have enough sense and decency to minimalize casualties. As long as we don't have another My Lai or Abu Gharib, I'm optimistic.

All the same, kill us some terrorists, boys! Hooah!
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: FaustWolf on September 11, 2009, 06:15:23 pm
The My Lai massacre showed the worst and best of the American spirit. Hugh Thompson, Jr., is the kind of hero you'd only expect to see in a very well-written drama; (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugh_Thompson,_Jr.) in fact, I'm surprised they haven't already made a movie about that episode.

It doesn't help us that people are accusing Hamid Karzai of stuffing ballot boxes just like Ahmadinejad next door.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: ZombieBucky on September 11, 2009, 08:41:09 pm
my aunt and i were never close. she lived out in cali for some reason, even though the rest of my family lives out here in connecticut. she moved there with her husband. she had flown over here to visit us. apparently my dad and she were close. i always regarded her as the insane cat loving aunt that everyone has. she smelled of weird old lady perfume and cat litter. for some reason her flight wasnt out of hartford but out of boston. my dad drove her there and she got on the plane. dunno which flight it was.
at school i was in english. we werent doing anything; we had just taken a test so we were goofing off. one of the kids asked to put on the television because we were sick of playing card games. the teacher turned on the television...
... and we saw a plane hit the second tower.
we were like 'HOLY SHIT MAN WHAT THE HELL' and my teacher was like 'HOLY FUCK!!' (no lie) we watched and we told all the other teachers and they had a lot of reactions. one of them wasnt sure if we were spinning a tale (i was notorious for that kind of thing) and another thought it was just a television program. but then they turned on their televisions and were like 'hot damn.'

when i got home my dad was all panicky. he told me that my aunt was on one of those flights. shes presumed dead.
i find it strange how when something like this happens you change how you think of them. before i thought of all the crazy shit she did and how she smelled of old lady house. now i find that old lady house smell comforting and think of only the good times with her, like before she moved to cali. she took me sledding once. she also brought me a lot of souvenirs from cali. i still have a ticky tacky snowglobe with hollywood in it, as well as a teddybear with some kind of california signet on it.

i guess ive moved on though. i dont feel sad anymore.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: mav on September 11, 2009, 09:14:16 pm
What do you guys think of the war in Afghanistan nowadays? I get this sense that the media is treating it like another Vietnam (just like how they eventually treated the Iraq War to a considerable degree) but I'm glad the US has its "eye on the ball" again, so to speak. Now if we could stop killing Afghan civilians -- even on a strategic level, that's going to come back to bite us in the ass.
Iraq is still treated like Vietnam, in my opinion. Afghanistan, on the other hand, seems to be the forgotten war: people don't remember when it began, why we're there, what we're doing, how it's going, etc. The killing of civilians is deplorable, regardless of where it is, so why the hell does no one seem to care? That story was barely reported on...And apparently a majority of US citizens (well, technically just the people polled) feel that we should pull out of Afghanistan now...Or maybe they feel that we're "losing"? Madness.


By the way, is it me or does it seem like more people have gotten over 9/11? I didn't see the US pride shirts, or American flag lapels, or anything like that. I didn't get a chance to watch the news today, but I'm sure most of it was just token nods to eight years ago.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: FaustWolf on September 11, 2009, 10:58:08 pm
I'm really sorry to hear about your aunt Zombie. If it was out of Boston, it was either American Airlines Flight 11 or United Airlines 175 from what I understand. Damn...

Last year the Obama Campaign shut down for the day in memory of the tragedy. If it's beginning to slip from peoples' minds, politicians remain utterly careful not to offend those who still keep this day...er, semi-sacred, or however you'd call it.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Vehek on September 11, 2009, 11:05:44 pm
Eight years...
I don't even remember what I was doing then, or how I felt.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 12, 2009, 12:02:42 am
Knock Knock

Who's there?

9/11

9/11 who?

YOU SAID YOU'D NEVER FORGET!
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: Truthordeal on September 12, 2009, 12:25:55 am
Well, the wounds have healed up, especially after this past year of bitter cynicism. Today will always hold a significant place in our heart, just as the bombing of Pearl Harbor does for our grandparents. That'll never go away.

But to use an analogy, it seems that our wounds have scabbed up, and its best not to poke at it and make it fester. Don't drag yourself through the memory anymore than is necessary.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 12, 2009, 03:40:42 am
This is actually the year that I've really cracked a joke about 9/11.

I guess now that Bush is gone that cloud has been lifted and we can finally feel free.

One last note: Does California have a budget?

♪ Unless it's a budget
--Without taxes!

One final note, I live in California, and we're still don't have a budget.

September 11th has come and gone once again. So yet again, I close this topic. Hopefully by this time next year, California will have a budget.

I can't remember if we finally passed one or not. If we don't, this is exactly why I'm getting the fuck out of here.

EDIT: Well, The 11th has come and gone, the topic will be locked away as usual. Blah Blah Blah Never forget.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 11, 2010, 05:54:39 pm
Blah blah blah, 9/11, blah blah blah have some cake!

(http://img827.imageshack.us/img827/7125/happy9112.jpg)
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: tushantin on September 12, 2010, 05:13:30 am
Bleh, this guy doesn't even deserve a cake, unless it's a poisoned one...
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: utunnels on September 12, 2010, 05:39:12 am
Nah, what do you have to do before eating a cake?
Chopping it into pieces of course.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: GenesisOne on September 12, 2010, 05:45:33 pm

Why anybody would trivialize 9/11 by turning it into a birthday cake is beyond me. It is both macabre and purile. To the person who ever finds the decorator for this cake, do me a favor: push him or her down a flight of stairs for even conceiving such an idea.
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: FaustWolf on September 12, 2010, 06:22:37 pm
The cake brings up a timely question though:

Which is more distasteful? The cake or the mosque that's purported to be built two blocks away?

I think the American populace would do itself a big favor by asking this question, and examining the deeper meaning behind the answer.

(PS: The cake is a lie!)
Title: Re: Never Forget...
Post by: nightmare975 on September 13, 2010, 02:11:54 am
Nine years... not much to talk about anymore.

Blah blah blah Never forget.